c is for cat

Rules for Anchorites

Letters from Proxima Thule

Previous Entry Share Next Entry
From the "You're Not Helping" Files
perfect girls
catvalente
You know, I hate to say this, from one woman to another, one artist to another. It's not a respectful thing to say, and to some extent I want to be respectful to people who inspire, challenge, and act out.

But for the love of spangles, shut up, Lady Gaga.

From an interview in the Japanese magazine, Giselle:

Lady Gaga declares she is bisexual as she appears on the cover of Japanese magazine Giselle. The 'Pokerface' singer appears on the latest issue of the publication with her hair in her trademark bow. Inside she says she could easily get with a girl but looks for relationships with men. "I am bisexual," she says. "I can go out with girls but in my opinion, love and sex are different."

My eyes went a little crossed when I read that. That is not coming out as bisexual. That's playing to the same old stupid shit of tee hee, I kissed a girl, but I only want to marry you, big boy.

I know Gaga is a gay icon and all, and most female gay icons are actually totally straight. But I don't feel that saying you could never have a real relationship with a woman and don't even look for them means you get to stick a bisexual banner on your bra and march at the head of the Pride Parade as some kind of queer sexual revolutionary. If you only want relationships with men--and she's not only saying she's only had relationships with men in the past, but only looks for them with men now, and could never love a woman--well, you know, I have a hard time seeing what's so thrillingly queer about that.

And you know, bisexual women have quite a hard enough time being accepted as a legitimate sexuality in this world without people grabbing the label (people who through wealth and fame have elevated themselves out of any culture that would bring them negative consequences for it) and then giggling that girls are cute and all, but they're not exactly husband-material, amirite?

We have a hard enough time getting relationships between women acknowledged and counted. We have a hard enough time being taken seriously as women not actually performing for the arousal of men. We have a hard enough time being in any relationship at all--date a man and you're not gay enough, date a woman and you're probably just doing it for attention. You know, til a real man comes along. We have a hard enough time without one of the most vocal and self-sexualized figures in pop culture saying shit like that. It's not edgy. It doesn't make you anymore hardcore, punk rock, awesome or liberated than Katy Perry singing that awful song.

There's no respect in saying you're bisexual and wrapping it up in a big bow that reads: maybe if I'm drunk enough I'll touch her boobs but I'm going home with a dude.

For some of us, coming out has consequences, and is difficult, and brave. For some of us, Pride is so hard to come by. Thanks for making that cheap, Gaga.

I'm having a hard time tracking down anything other than a cover and that quote from that interview, so I can't really judge - that seems like too little context to go by, and I like data before drawing conclusions.

So I'll present another case, from Barbara Walter's 2009 interview:
“I do like women,” the 23-year-old responded. “I’ve only been in love with men. I’ve never been in love with a woman. But that’s really what the song is all about—why, when I was with my boyfriend, was I fantasizing about women?”

Not content to leave it at that, Walters then asked point blank if she’s ever had sex with women. After stumbling over her words a bit, Gaga replied, “I’ve certainly had sexual relationships with women.”
(http://idolator.com/5318651/barbara-walters-cant-get-enough-of-lady-gagas-sex-talk)

Unfortunately I can't find the Rolling Stone interview from last year online, where she talks about her gay fans and how she explained to Kanye West that if they were going to do a tour together gay people would come to the show, in addition to talking about her relationship status, etc, but I can find clips such as this one:
But Gaga says that she has never truly been in love with a woman and that the attraction is based off of totally physical aspects. (http://www.celebrity-gossip.net/celebrities/hollywood/lady-gaga-talks-bisexuality-213803 )
(I did read the interview at the time, but it's been 6 months.)

I'm going to go out on a limb and say that whatever Giselle quoted her as, it's been her stated preference since she came out more than a year ago, and is internally consistent.